
For a few hundred dollars you can buy a debt of the Chinese state. The certificate is half a metre wide, engraved in London by Waterlow & Sons, and dated 15 June 1911. It promises 5% a year in gold.1 It has paid nothing since 1938. An American bondholders' group nonetheless says that claims on bonds of this kind add up to $1.6 trillion, and for a few months in 2020 collectors paid up as if it might be right.2
This is the story of how a railway loan helped end an empire, why its holders are still trying to collect, and what two earlier settlements say about their chances.

A loan that helped end a dynasty
The Hukuang Railways loan was signed on 20 May 1911 between the Qing government and banks from Britain, France, Germany and the United States, each country taking a quarter of £6 million.3 The American share was political. President Taft had pressed for it as part of his "dollar diplomacy", and J.P. Morgan and Kuhn, Loeb put their names on the New York tranche.4
The money was meant to build lines from Hankou south to Canton and west into Sichuan. The loan came with the nationalisation of railway projects that provincial investors had already paid into, and protecting the foreign lenders was widely seen as an attack on Chinese sovereignty. Protests spread, and in October 1911 an uprising at Wuchang began the revolution.5 Eight months after the bonds were issued, the dynasty had abdicated.

The railway fared little better. A CIA memorandum written in 1983 found no evidence that the proceeds were ever spent on the Hankou to Canton line, which was finished only in 1937. Part of the money went "into official pockets".6

Default, then silence
The Republic that followed kept the loan alive for two decades and went on borrowing abroad. Interest on the Hukuang bonds was paid on time until December 1930. A rescheduling proposed in the spring of 1937 was never carried out, because war with Japan broke out that July. After two half payments, the last in June 1938, the bonds went silent.7 When the People's Republic was founded in 1949, its leaders declined to honour the debts of earlier regimes, though they never formally cancelled them.8 The paper drifted out of brokers' ledgers and into albums and attics.

The day an Alabama court said yes
American holders tried the courts first. In 1979 a group led by Russell Jackson sued the People's Republic in a federal court in Alabama over their Hukuang bonds. China did not appear, and in 1982 the judge awarded the bondholders $41.3 million.9 China then contested the ruling, the United States government filed a statement supporting its right to do so, and the judgment was set aside in 1984. Two years later the appeal court closed the door: the 1976 law that lets Americans sue foreign states over commercial dealings does not reach back to a bond issued in 1911.10
That left politics.
From the courtroom to the trade war
The claims have since been taken up by the American Bondholders Foundation, a Tennessee group co-founded in 2001 to represent holders of the old debt. In 2019 the Trump administration was reported to be studying whether the bonds could be revived as leverage against Beijing.11
By July 2020, with Covid and the trade war feeding talk of sending Beijing the bill, Izabella Kaminska reported that the antique bonds were back in play. The foundation, she wrote, says it represents $1.6 trillion in claims, a figure that includes decades of compound interest. Mitu Gulati, a law professor at Duke, told her that in the right diplomatic setting holders might argue for a "set off" against the Treasuries China owns.12
The market noticed. George LaBarre, an American dealer in old securities, told Kaminska that the 1911 Hukuang bond had gone from between $75 and $100 to about $450.13 Nothing about the object had changed. Buyers were paying for an option on a presidential mood. Kaminska's own verdict was cautious: the legal merit of the claims is debatable, and buyers may simply have hoped that rhetoric alone would lift prices.
That distinction still matters. A certificate bought as a collectible is one thing. A certificate bought as a stake in a future settlement is a bet on diplomacy, and should be weighed as one.
Video: the American Bondholders Foundation presents its claim.
What Thatcher actually got
The strongest argument for the bondholders is that China has paid before. On 5 June 1987 Britain and China signed an agreement in Beijing settling all historical claims between them, including bonds issued by Chinese governments before 1949. China paid £23,468,008.14
Three details matter more than the headline. The sum had to cover seized property as well as bonds, when the sterling bonds alone had a face value of about £60 million. Holders were paid a percentage of face value, so at best a fraction of their principal after half a century without interest.15 Only bonds in British hands on the eve of signing qualified, which shut out anyone hoping to buy cheaply abroad and claim in London. And the settlement was mutual. It came, as Kaminska notes, when China wanted to enter London's capital markets and the return of Hong Kong was on the table.16
That is the lesson of 1987. A bond settlement is a by-product of diplomacy. Beijing paid when it wanted something from the other side. It is hard to see what it wants from Washington today that paying a century-old railway loan would buy.
The Russian mirror
The closest parallel is older. On 8 February 1918 the Soviet government repudiated the Tsar's debts, a large share of them held in France.17 The bonds kept trading in Paris anyway. Kim Oosterlinck and John Landon-Lane have shown that their prices moved with each rumour of a bailout, a negotiation or a White Army victory, pricing in rescues that never came.18
When money finally arrived, it was small and political. Britain's 1986 deal with Gorbachev returned about 2% of what was owed.19 France settled in 1997 for $400 million, to be shared among several hundred thousand claimants, and holders' associations were still suing, and losing, in 2015.20
What the collector actually owns
So what is a Hukuang bond worth? As a claim, the precedents suggest somewhere between nothing and a few pence in the pound, payable only to the citizens of a government that strikes a deal. As an object, rather more. It is common enough to be affordable and comes in variants that reward attention: £20 and £100 denominations, in green or red, issued through British, German, French and American banks, each with its own signatures and serial ranges.21 Prices vary widely with denomination, issuing bank and condition, so compare several dealers and auction results before buying.
Buy it for the engraving, the revolution and the paper. The trillion dollars is not included.
This article is history, not investment advice.














Join the discussion
Financial History Institute Editorial invitation
What do you think? Share your perspective, questions or historical insights below. We welcome a thoughtful discussion.
Comments are reviewed before appearing. Your name and comment will be public once approved.